Didn't see the boot-off American Idol until last night (taped it so we could watch the final episode of Manor House), so the surprise introduction of Ruben to the bottom group (now two rather than three) waited a day. He didn't get the heave-ho, but rather Trenyce was the night's victim. Actually, the real victim was "What the World Needs Now" sung by 9 of the 12 finalists (missing were felon-in-training Corey Clark, and the two early rejectees who've spoken out against Big Brother, Vanessa and Charles) while being conducted by Burt Bacharach. The cut will apparently appear on his new album. I suppose I shouldn't argue; it's better than any version of "God Bless the USA."

Josh, who probably should have been voted off, seemed distraught with the possibility that he'd remain and Ruben wouldn't, suggesting that even he realizes his talent level doesn't justify continued appearances on the show. He's this season's R. J. Helton, just with better phone support (someone check the Pentagon's dialing records). Considering that one of the upcoming weeks will involve the Bee Gees, Josh may not be around too much longer. He's proven disco isn't his forte.